I Will Not Leave You Orphaned

Meditation on John 14

Rev. Dr. Karen Crawford

First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown, NY

Nov. 17, 2026

In Memory of Jean Lown

Dec. 4, 1933-November 8, 2026

She was always there when her family needed her.

Jean Lown prepared bag lunches for her husband and two children every school night. Without fail. For years.

She made sandwiches of peanut butter and jelly, sandwiches of cream cheese and jelly, sandwiches of cold cuts. She tucked in chocolate pudding cups and fruit before placing each neatly folded bag on a different shelf for daughter, Beth, son Bill, and husband Bill, who worked as a teacher, coach, and athletic director. 

She made her own bag lunch, too, when she worked as an elementary school substitute for Brentwood and Smithtown school districts until Beth, her youngest, was in 7th grade. Bill laughed when he told me that she subbed for his class while he was in kindergarten. He sounded proud. For the last 8 or 10 years of her more than 30-year teaching career, she led the Resource Room, teaching reading and math at Mount Pleasant Elementary School in Smithtown, less than a mile from their home.

Her family always came first. She drove them to and from sports practices and games on Saturdays. And she drove other people’s children to and from sports practices and games on Saturdays.

Their happy life included the nurture of faith and hope at First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown, beginning in the 1960s. After Jean retired from teaching, along with having more time for long walks, 9-hole golf, and doubles tennis, she became an active volunteer with her church, finding joy and friendship while counting the offering.

Jean was born on Dec. 4, 1933, to Oscar and Emma Sliva. She and her younger brother, Philip, grew up in Eastchester, New York. Oscar was a polish immigrant who strung together a living and supported his family by working two jobs as a plumber and baker. Jean’s mother was a German immigrant who stayed home to care for her family. They knew English but spoke German in the home until World War II when they feared they would be ostracized because of their language and culture.

Jean’s parents valued education and passed that value on to her and Philip. They made sure that both would go to college so that they would have opportunities that Oscar and Emma never had. They encouraged them in their interests.

In high school, Jean was a cheerleader. At University of New York at Cortland, she joined a sorority and had many friends. They also became teachers on Long Island and remained lifelong friends. Because they spent so much time together as families, Jean’s children assumed that everybody’s parents had summers off and went to the beach with their families and friends with their families.

Jean was always supportive of her husband’s career and of him, in general—ever since they met in college. They worked hard and saved money to ensure that their children would be able to go to college and not be burdened by student loan debt.

When young Bill got to college, he saw what other students were going through with their troubled families and realized how very lucky he and Beth were to have the parents that they did. How unbelievable their two parents were! The environment they created in the home on Columbus Avenue in Smithtown, where his parents lived for more than 50 years.

Jean and Bill warmly welcomed Bill’s college friend to their home when he didn’t want to spend Thanksgiving break with his own family. The friend told Bill recently, “I always felt like I was a foster son in your family.” Coming from a home where there was often tension and arguments, the friend saw up close with Jean and husband Bill, who never argued in front of their children, how much love could make a difference.

This passage in the gospel of John is about love—a love that lasts forever, a love that gives us confidence and hope as we live in this world. This is the love of God shown through Jesus, the Son, who was preparing his friends—with whom he had shared his life and ministry for 3 years—for what was to come. “In a little while the world will no longer see me,” he says of his suffering death looming ahead. “But you will see me,” he says, hinting of the resurrection—his and ours with him. “Because I live, you also will live.”

Now through his death, our Savior would prepare a place for them and for you and for me and all his followers a new home with our Heavenly Parent in a house of many dwelling places or rooms. And though the separation would be painful and bring much grief, he didn’t want them to be overcome by fear and doubt. He wanted to strengthen them to carry on with the ministry when he was no longer with them in the flesh. “Do not let your hearts be troubled,” Jesus says. Don’t worry. “Believe in God; believe also in me.”

Jesus assured them that this separation would not be for long. “And if I go and prepare a place for you,” he says, “I will come again and take you to myself, so that where I am, there you may be also.”

As Bill shared stories with me a few days ago of his mom and dad and his life in a happy, secure, and loving home growing up, he suddenly said, “Now I am an orphan.”

That’s how we feel when our parents, who have been with us our whole lives, go home to be with the Lord. It changes how we feel about ourselves and may stir us to question the mysteries of life and the everlasting. It stirs us to reconsider our childhoods, when we who are blessed to have our parents with us in our adulthood never once thought about what life would be like after they are gone.

But listen. We aren’t ever alone, not even in this world. For Jesus has kept his promise and sent his Comforter, the Holy Spirit, to be with us always. “You know him,” our Lord assures us, “because he abides with you, and he will be in you.” And we have our sisters and brothers in the Body of Christ throughout the world ready to support and comfort us in our times of vulnerability. “I will not leave you orphaned,” Jesus says.

And this is our hope. One day, we will be with him face to face, and he will wipe our tears away. There will be no more pain or suffering, no more death or dying. And we will have glad reunion with our loved ones in the Father’s house of many dwelling places, many rooms. This is a house much like the home of your childhood, Bill and Beth. You truly were lucky and blessed to have a glimpse of what the future holds. And you know the way to get there is by faith, as Jesus says, “Believe in God. Believe also in me.”

In the world to come, everyone, even those without happy, secure childhood homes, will feel the perfect, unconditional love and security of God the Father, Spirit, and Son, who says to all who are struggling with grief and anxiety for tomorrow,

“Do not let your hearts be troubled. Do not let them be afraid.”

Amen.

Kingdom Investments

Meditation on Matthew 25:14–29

First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown

Rev. Dr. Karen Crawford

Nov. 17, 2026

Art by Stushie, used with permission

It sure was cold yesterday! Did anyone else think it was cold? I wore my winter coat! I was thinking yesterday, on my way home from the presbytery meeting, that before you know it, we’ll be getting ready for Christmas! Today, don’t laugh, but I am in the mood for watching one of my favorite Christmas movies. It’s a Wonderful Life.

That Jimmy Stewart was something else, wasn’t he? And the movie has so many good themes–generosity, home and family, perseverance in trials, clinging to hope, and the strength and acceptance of community. But it’s also a love story. George Bailey walks Mary home from the dance and they are singing their special song,

Buffalo gals, won’t you come out tonight?
Come out tonight, come out tonight?
Buffalo gals, won’t you come out tonight?
And dance by the light of the moon?

George says to Mary, “You want the moon? Just say the word and I’ll throw a lasso around it and pull it down.”

It’s hard to believe that when the movie first came out in 1946, it was a box office flop, and his first film appearance in 5 years– after serving in World War II. Jimmy had a successful film career when he surprised quite a few people and became the first major American movie star to enlist. He was, in fact, living out his boyhood dream “of becoming a Navy pilot, serving during WWII and for decades afterward. In 1985, he was awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom for his contributions to American culture and for his dedicated military service.”[1]

Jimmy grew up in a Scots-Irish Presbyterian family in rural Indiana, PA, a coal-mining town. He was the eldest of three and the only son. His father, Alexander, ran the family hardware store in town. The J.M. Stewart and Company Hardware Store was named after James’s paternal grandfather, whom he was also named after, and was established in 1853. Jimmy’s dad hoped that his son would “take over the shop after attending university, just as he had done for J.M. (But Jimmy), who spent much of his childhood piecing together model airplanes in the basement, had other hopes.”[2]

He studied architecture at Princeton, and “joined … a student group that produced original musicals.” He was offered a scholarship for graduate studies after writing his thesis on airport terminal design, “but he chose to take a chance on the stage. He joined … an intercollegiate summer stock company performing in Cape Cod.”  At the end of the season, “he and a couple of his performer friends packed up and moved to the Big Apple to try their luck on Broadway. In 1935, he signed a seven-year contract with Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer… And later was loaned to Columbia Studios for Frank Capra’s 1938 film ‘You Can’t Take It With You.’ The film won the Academy Award for Best Picture that year, propelling Jimmy from minor role-player to major star. Next was his role as a U.S. senator in Capra’s 1939 ‘Mr. Smith Goes to Washington’ and then ‘The Philadelphia Story’ with Katherine Hepburn and Cary Grant, for which he won the Oscar for Best Actor.”

After earning his wings with the Army Air Corps in August of 1942, he taught cadets, starred in educational and recruitment films, and acted as commander of a bomber squadron. He flew 20 missions over enemy territory, returning to the U.S. in 1945 as a colonel — making him one of the few Americans to ever rise from private to colonel in only four years. Upon his return in 1945, he was decorated with the Distinguished Flying Cross and set off for Indiana to check in on his folks.

He had to talk to his father about a certain psalm. Alex Stewart had been there to see off his son in November 1943, when he slipped a note into Jim’s pocket that he’d later discover during his flight to London. It read: ‘My dear Jim boy. Soon after you read this letter, you will be on your way to the worst danger … Jim, I’m banking on the enclosed copy of the 91st Psalm…I am staking my faith in these words. I feel sure that God will lead you through this mad experience…. I can say no more. I only continue to pray …”[3] The Psalm begins in the King James, “He that dwelleth in the secret place of the most High shall abide under the shadow of the Almighty. I will say of the Lord, He is my refuge and my fortress: my God; in him will I trust. Surely he shall deliver thee from the snare of the fowler, and from the noisome pestilence. He shall cover thee with his feathers, and under his wings shalt thou trust: his truth shall be thy shield and buckler. Thou shalt not be afraid for the terror by night; nor for the arrow that flieth by day.”

Returning home from the war, his father’s psalm in hand, Jimmy was feeling a bit lost. He was considering moving back to Indiana and working at the family store when his old friend Frank Capra approached him with “It’s a Wonderful Life.” It wasn’t like any role Jimmy had played before. And it allowed him to express the sadness and grief of a man who wasn’t sure what his future would be, a war veteran, who had trouble re-entering the life that he had before WWII,  a faithful man seeking God’s will for his life and perhaps struggling with, if not PTSD, something close to it. 

The Parable of the Talents in Matthew isn’t really about our understanding of “talents” at all. A talent in the Bible was the largest unit of currency in the Greek and Roman world and not a personal skill or aptitude. The passage seems to be about money and wise investing. And yet it isn’t wrong to interpret this passage beyond its surface meaning. Because the Lord wants ALL of us, every part of us—all that God has made us, all that we have, all that we will become with God’s help. What else could it mean when Christ invites his disciples to deny themselves, take up their crosses, and follow him?

A talent in New Testament times weighed about 75 pounds of gold or silver and was equal to about 6,000 denarii. One denarius was the standard daily wage for a common laborer. At this rate, he would have to work 15 to 20 years to earn 6,000 denarii. In today’s money, one source said that a New Testament talent may be as much as 1 million USD. That means that when he gave 5, 2, and 1 talent to three different slaves, he was giving them a huge amount of money: today’s 5 million, 2 million, and 1 million dollars. This phrase “according to his ability” stands out to me because the Lord does have different expectations and gifts for each one of us. But always, we are expected to be faithful in our Kingdom Investments no matter how little or how much we are given. 

I think about how each of us are given a wonder-filled life, really, yet not an easy one, because we are always seeking God’s will and listening for God’s voice. Life is full of challenges, choices, and forks in the road where decisions impact not only us, but our loved ones, too.  When we follow Christ in our own lives, what we are trying to do is make sure that we invest into the kingdom by saying yes to the opportunities God presents for us to develop our gifts and grow our resources, and then serve the Lord with our gifts and resources. Every time we love others through our acts of kindness and giving, our treasure in the heavenly kingdom grows and the world in which we live becomes a better place.

Jimmy married Gloria Hatrick McLean at Brentwood Presbyterian Church in LA three years after the release of “It’s a Wonderful Life.” The church remembers him and his bride fondly, saying at its website that “not everyone knows that Jimmy Stewart was an instrumental part of the building of the church.” He “started attending there after one of his father’s visits. Alex arrived in California and promptly asked his son where he spent his Sundays.

When Jimmy stammered something about there not being one nearby, Alex disappeared down the road, only to return with four other men in tow. ‘You must not have looked very hard, Jim,’ his father said to him, ‘because there’s a Presbyterian church just three blocks from here, and these are the elders.” Apparently, the congregation was building a new sanctuary, and Alex assured them not to worry, saying to his son, ‘I told them you were a movie star, and you would help them.’”

Jimmy didn’t hesitate to give the church his money and even more. He made a true Kingdom investment—of his whole heart, mind, and soul. The church became his worship home and a place of refuge and prayer, especially when his wife Gloria fell ill after their twins were born. Later when the Stewarts moved from Brentwood to Beverly Hills and began attending Beverley Hills Presbyterian Church, Jim was called to serve as a ruling elder. I can just picture Jimmy serving on Session. Can’t you? He remained “active in the Air Force Reserves and attained the rank of brigadier general in July 1959 and retired from service on May 31, 1968.

The private man refused all attempts by the press for interviews and speaking engagements during his military career. He continued to make films, made a re-entry into Broadway, starred in some Westerns, and collaborated with Alfred Hitchcock, all while he and Gloria raised their children together. When Jimmy went home to be with God on July 2, 1997, more than 3,000 mourners attended his memorial. I can imagine his master saying to him in heaven, “Well done, good and trustworthy servant; you have been trustworthy in a few things; I will put you in charge of many things; enter into the joy of your master.”

Of all the characters he played in his more than 80 films, I still like Jimmy’s vulnerable portrayal of George Bailey the best. That magical story of Bedford Falls reminds us of the love, grace, and mercy of our God, always ready to forgive and bless us with a new beginning when George prays earnestly for a second chance at his wonderful life, “I wanna live again. I wanna live again. I want to live again. Please, God, let me live again.”

Let us pray.

Gracious God, thank you for your love, grace, and mercy for sinners, always ready to forgive and bless us with a new beginning when we pray. Thank you for our church family, a community of faith that is always accepting of one another. Help us to be truly grateful for the wonderful life you have given us and the promise of eternal life through your Son. Teach us about Kingdom investing. Show us how to grow our heavenly treasure through acts of kindness and love. Lead us to live gently and generously, persevering in trials, and clinging to our hope in you. Strengthen and guide us by your Holy Spirit so that we never fail to make the most of every opportunity that you present to us, and to use our gifts, talents, and resources for your Kingdom and your glory. And we pray for our American veterans. Comfort and heal them and grant them peace as they seek to re-enter civilian life after their military service. Direct their steps, build their faith, and surround them with your grace and love. Stir us to minister to them. In the name of our Savior Jesus Christ we pray. Amen.


[1] “Meet Jimmy Stewart” in Presbyterian Outlook, Dec. 25, 2025, reprinted from a story by Presbyterian News Service, accessed November 14, 2026 at https://pres-outlook.org/2025/12/meet-jimmy-stewart/?cache_busting=6af8df754a509

[2] “Meet Jimmy Stewart” in Presbyterian Outlook, Dec. 25, 2025.

[3] Meet Jimmy Stewart” in Presbyterian Outlook, Dec. 25, 2025.

Give Us Some of Your Oil!

Meditation on Matthew 25:1-13

Rev. Dr. Karen Crawford

Nov. 8, 2026 (Baptism of Margot and Jack)

Ruth Roman was one of 10 children, raised in an abusive household. She endured an abusive marriage and a period of homelessness. She turned to drugs and doing whatever she could to survive. She didn’t believe in God or Jesus. She didn’t know that she was loved and forgiven. Not until nine years ago, when she started attending the New Jerusalem Church in Saint James and heard her pastor preach. After that, everything changed. She became a person of hope and compassion and prayer. She had a whole new purpose for her life—not just survival, but seeking to follow him and help others to know him, too.

About 7 years ago, the pastor asked her to serve as the director of the Food Pantry there. She said yes, and the ministry grew under her leadership. Today, many volunteers help prepare the bags distributed on Wednesday nights to about 80 families. Some people come all the way from Queens. And they don’t just come for food. They come to share their problems. Ruth offers to pray with each person. Then, during the pandemic, she started a bilingual ministry called “Gracious Givers of Long Island.” Volunteers deliver food to people who can’t come to the food pantry; they help people with pay utility bills or for prescription drugs, and other generous acts of kindness. She has been invited to share her testimony with schools and Girl Scouts. Retired police officers bring troubled teens, kids doing what it takes to survive, to help with the food pantry. She invites them to church, so they, too, might meet the Lord and be changed.

What is all this talk about having lamps, falling asleep, and not having enough oil in Jesus’ parable of the 10 bridesmaids? Why did the foolish demand of the wise bridesmaids, when their lamps went out, “Give us some of your oil?” But it was too late.

The Confirmation class and I, along with some adults, visited Temple Isaiah in Stony Brook three years ago for a Shabbat service. Shabbat is the Hebrew word for rest. Shabbat Shalom means peaceful rest. One of the most moving aspects of the worship was during a Hebrew song called “Lekha Dodi,” when everyone stands and turns to face the door and welcome Shabbat as if she is a beloved bride. “Come out my Beloved, the Bride to meet,” the song begins in English. “The inner light of Shabbat, let us greet.”

Joy filled the room. I was reminded, then, that the Sabbath is more than just a commandment, a day God set aside to refrain from work when our Creator was finished creating. This is God’s gift of Sabbath rest and peace, foreshadowing the wedding banquet of the Messiah, when the Sabbath won’t just be one day a week; it will be ours to enjoy with God and one another for all eternity. The Shabbat bride, therefore, is a metaphor for the time of redemption. When the Messiah comes, everyone will live in peace and rest forever.

This is what Jesus means with his parable. He was Jewish, after all, as was his first audience. Everyone knew that he was talking about the day of redemption: who would be ready to meet the Messiah, and who would not. Who would have the oil of faith to light their lanterns and join the Bridegroom in the eternal wedding banquet. And who would not.

I think God was waiting patiently for Ruth to realize there was something missing from her life. That life isn’t just to be endured. It isn’t just survival, doing whatever it takes. Life is meant to be lived by giving and sharing, spreading hope and kindness, reaching out to help people and in doing so, being filled to overflowing with the joy of the Lord.

Reading this passage, I am stirred by the metaphor of the foolish bridesmaids who did have lamps and oil and were waiting and longing for the Bridegroom with the other bridesmaids. They did have some faith! But it wasn’t enough. It ran out while they were waiting. When they fell asleep, I think they just grew weary and stopped believing that today or tonight could be the very day that the Messiah comes again. They let their oil run out and their faith no longer guided and filled their life with purpose and meaning.

And I ask myself, would I live my life differently if I lived as if I were sure that Christ could return at any moment? I am a woman of faith, but at the same time, I am always busy preparing for the next thing scheduled on my ministry calendar. Those anxious preparations and worrying about all the details can steal our joy, can’t they? And none of it really prepares us for Christ’s coming again. And what if Christ comes tonight? This afternoon, even? All that worry for the future would be for nothing. Amen?

I met Ruth Roman yesterday morning, when Marci Deakins, Isabel Buse, and I went to visit her at the New Jerusalem Church. We were there to present Ruth with a check and a letter explaining the Charlotte Cheatham Hunger Relief Fund and the woman—Charlotte Cheatham—who started it all with her passion to help people in need. After Ruth shared her story, Marci and Isabel shared about Charlotte Cheatham. They spoke of her concern for people living in poverty, not having enough food to eat. And how she and Estelle Edwards and Lois Netter went to Washington and lobbied for aid for people living with food insecurity. That passion to help people in need led Charlotte’s husband, Ed, to start the fund after she went home to be with God in 2009. When Ed passed away last October, his family asked the Session to distribute the remaining money to organizations feeding the hungry on Long Island. The New Jerusalem Church Food Pantry was one of about 18 food pantries and soup kitchens receiving grants ranging from $500 to $6,000 this year.

Today, we welcomed two little children into the Church through Baptism. Margot Wren and Jack Thomas are claimed by their Lord and filled with spiritual gifts to strengthen them to keep choosing to follow Christ all their days. Today is a new beginning for them and for us, who were reminded of the joy of our baptisms and our calling to nurture all the children in faith, hope, love—to help ensure that their lamps will never go out.

When I told Ruth that the check was for $6,000, she cried. Staring at the check, wiping away tears, she thanked us, over and over again. She couldn’t wait to tell her pastor –the one who shared the gospel with her nine years ago that changed her life and lit her lamp

with oil.

She has become a person of hope and compassion and prayer with a whole new purpose for her life—not just her own survival but seeking to follow Christ and help others know him. She wants to be ready and awake with her lamp aflame.

Friends, do you have enough oil for your lamp? Does your faith guide and fill your life with purpose and meaning or are you just surviving? Are you ready for the day of redemption?

It may be midnight. It may dawn. No one knows the day or hour when the Messiah will

beckon us to the wedding banquet, a feast of forever Sabbath rest and peace, like the song we sang at Temple Isaiah.

“Come out my Beloved, the Bride to meet. The inner light of Shabbat, let us greet.”

Let us pray.

Holy One, we await our Bridegroom, our Messiah, with joyous anticipation. We trust in your love and mercy for us. Thank you for our faith, which is a gracious gift from you. Thank you for calling us to a life of purpose and meaning, to live not just to survive day by day but to care for others, including those living in poverty and food insecurity. Strengthen us to share our testimonies so that others come to know you more. Thank you for stirring us to love one another and nurture all who are baptized throughout their journeys of faith, helping to ensure that their lamps and ours will never go out. Come quickly, Lord. We are ready to let go of the worries of today and tomorrow and enter into the joy that you have prepared for us, the feast of forever Sabbath rest and peace. In Christ’s name we pray. Amen.

Love for All the Saints

Meditation on Ephesians 1:11-23

Rev. Dr. Karen Crawford

First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown

All Saints Day

Nov. 1, 2026

Margaret met Hamish Cowie after the war, when she was working in housekeeping at a hotel. His sister, Sheila, introduced them. He was good looking, a police officer, but it wasn’t love at first sight, she said.

Margaret Murray was born on Jan. 22, 1921, to Catherine and William in the historic fishing village of Helmsdale, Scotland. Her father was a fisherman. Margaret was the second of six children. She was a good student and was recognized with a certificate and prize for cooking from Helmsdale Higher Grade Public School in 1934. The prize was the book, Great Expectations. Her service in the British military in World War II, beginning when she was 19, was the thing that she was most proud of. She kept a picture of herself in uniform from that time with a friend, who served with her, near her favorite chair.

She and Hamish were married on Nov. 24, 1948, in Margaret’s church in Helmsdale. The couple lived in Tain and Fearn while Hamish worked as a policeman. They had a son, John, then two daughters, Kathleen, and Sheila, after a long gap. The family emigrated to America on July 5, 1959, and came to live and work in Commack with Hamish’s uncle who bred golden retrievers and had a small dog kennel. But their life in America was very different from their life in Scotland. And Margaret was terribly homesick. Bringing up three children in a country she didn’t know was almost too much for her in the beginning. Margaret said that if it hadn’t been for the Scottish immigrants on Long Island that they met through the Daughters of Scotia, she would have been on the first boat out of here.

She was strong, smart, funny. She knew how to make people laugh, wherever she was. And you would know the moment she started to speak that she wasn’t from around here, though she had lived on Long Island for more than 60 years. She learned to love American country music. The radio played 1050 Country all day long. Oh, and she did what many women in America did in the 1960s and 70s. She watched soap operas, such as “The Edge of Night,” whenever she ironed. She and Hamish gained a church family when they started attending the First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown in the 1960s. They quickly made friends. They were founding members of the Highlanders, which organized the Burns Supper each year, among other Scottish heritage events and activities.

Scotty was working a part-time job, guarding the ice at Belmont Lake State Park, making sure the kids didn’t go on thin ice and fall in. Joan’s friend, Margie, had said to her, “Joan, I have met the man that you are going to marry.” The first thing Joan noticed about him was his big smile and how joyful he seemed.

Harold Stanley Scott was born to Vivian and Roland Scott on April 10, 1934, on the South Shore of Long Island. Scotty had a younger sister, Ethel, who came along about two years later. Roland, their dad, had no education beyond high school. He was involved in local politics in the Town of Babylon. Scotty was baptized in the First Presbyterian Church of Babylon and his mother was Superintendent of the Sunday School. He was drawn to the Holy Scriptures at an early age. He memorized Psalm 23 as a young boy and never forgot it. He received a Bible on Sept. 24, 1944, from the Presbyterian Bible School in Babylon. He was confirmed and became a member of Babylon Presbyterian on June 1, 1949.

His pastor was strict and preached against drinking, dancing, and playing cards or BINGO. But Scotty always believed in a loving and gracious God whom he wanted to follow and please with his life. He had a love for music and enjoyed singing and playing the saxophone in his high school marching band. As a young man, he dreamed of becoming a dairy farmer. He graduated in 1954 from what was, at the time, SUNY Long Island Agricultural and Technical Institute at Farmingdale. But working on dairy farms in upstate New York for two summers opened his eyes to the difficult life, milking the cows twice a day and getting up at 4 a.m.

One day, a man from the State Health Department came to inspect the dairy farm where he was working. Scotty decided, from that moment on, that he wanted to be a health inspector, instead of a farmer. He landed a summer job working for the Suffolk County Health Department in Bay Shore. They were surprised by his maturity and work ethic; they offered him a career position. He received additional training and experience in the U.S. Air Force in 1957 working as an inspector for the food being served to the servicemen and women. He would eventually work for the Suffolk County Health Department office in Hauppauge, finish his bachelor’s degree from Empire State College in 1977, and retire from the health department after 33 years in 1990.

Are you wondering whatever happened to the boy and girl who met at Belmont Lake State Park in the early 1960s? Scotty called Joan a week or so later and they began dating. But it would be another 10 years of dating off and on before they decided to marry.  What was holding them back? Their religious differences. Joan was a faithful Roman Catholic who was never going to be Presbyterian. And Scotty was a faithful Presbyterian who was never going to be Catholic. They finally married in The Church of St. Mary in East Islip on Dec. 12, 1971. Through Scotty, Joan began to see the Lord in a new perspective—as Scotty saw the Lord as a loving and gracious God, merciful and quick to forgive. Every morning at the kitchen table, he led them in Bible reading, devotion, and prayer from Our Daily Bread. “He brought me peace and joy,” she says.

Scotty joined the First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown when the Rev. Bill Brown was the pastor. The couple began attending services at Sts. Philip and James Roman Catholic Church in St. James and the Presbyterian church in Smithtown every week for years, although Scotty did stand out in the Catholic church. “Catholics don’t sing,” Joan says, “and he’s belting out all the hymns.”

Today, on All Saints Day, we remember and give thanks for our siblings in the faith. We tell the stories of those dear to us who have gone home to be with God and yet are still with us, surrounding us, in the Great Cloud of Witnesses, cheering us on as we run the race of faith. We remember how their lives touched ours, how loving them and being loved by them has helped to make us who we are today. We speak once again of the hope that we have in Jesus Christ and the riches of our glorious inheritance not in the things of this world, but in Him who has redeemed us and made us God’s own people. We speak of the promise of our being marked and sealed by the Holy Spirit, so that we live not in fear, but with confidence, even as we grieve. We are moved to speak of the immeasurable greatness of Christ’s power for us who believe in the resurrection—not only Christ’s, but ours with Him. He is both with us now and seated at God’s right hand in the heavenly places. What’s more, his body and the fullness of him fills all in all. We have one ruler, dear friends, whose kingdom is not of this world, and yet we know him and feel his loving presence with all the saints. We have one who has all authority and power and dominion, one name above all names, not only in this age but also in the age to come.

You know, when I became a pastor years ago, I knew that I would be visiting my flock in homes, hospitals, and nursing homes, caring for people in their times of need. What I didn’t anticipate would be the depth of my grief when our members go to their heavenly home. How broken I would feel! This is what happens when we love the saints. This love that is a gift from God brings us great joy and deep sorrow. This love is a sign that we are Christ’s Disciples; we are the Body, the fullness of him that fills all in all.

Margaret went home to be with God on January 17, just a few days shy of her 105th birthday. I have missed my Sunday afternoon visits with Margaret, where she would be all dressed up and pretty with her soft sweaters and pins, and her daughter, Sheila, would come in with a tray of tea and shortbread. Margaret was curious and caring, always wanting to hear the latest news from her church, and was known for sending many cards and letters to remember birthdays and anniversaries and cheer someone who was sick or grieving. And she always made me laugh, just by giving me a look when I showed up at her door. “Oh, it’s you!” she used to say and roll her eyes. She would hold out her hands to me when we said goodbye.

Scotty went home to be with God on January 12. He would have been 92 in April. I have missed my visits with Scotty and Joan at their home in Smithtown and then at the Long Island Veterans Home, in a quiet, private place where we used to meet for Communion and catching up. I have missed his beautiful smile and sweet countenance—something he never lost though he struggled with Parkinsons. I have to tell you—Christmas caroling is not going to be the same this year. It brought us tears of joy these last two years, when Scotty, who lost his ability to speak in sentences, suddenly found his voice when we were singing. He would belt out the hymns, just like he did in the Catholic Church, when he embarrassed Joan. He didn’t need any music. He knew the words to all the verses!  “O Come All Ye Faithful.” “Silent Night.” “Joy to the World.”

Let us pray.

Holy One, thank you for your love and our being marked and sealed by your Spirit, filled with the immeasurable greatness of your power to live confidently as your own people. Thank you for the riches of our glorious inheritance and redemption in Christ, for opening the eyes of our hearts to our hope and the promise of our resurrection with Him. Thank you that we have nothing to fear, for we have One who has all authority and power and dominion, one name above all names, not only in this age but also in the age to come. Thank you for your Son who is with us now and forever and for our loved ones—for all the saints in the Great Cloud of Witnesses, surrounding us, cheering us on. Help us to live to your praise and glory. And comfort those who grieve, dear Lord. Grant them your peace and joy. Amen.

Created in Christ Jesus for Good Works

Meditation on Ephesians 2:1-10 for Reformation Sunday

Rev. Dr. Karen Crawford

First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown, NY

Oct. 25, 2026

Art by Stushie, used with permission

I received a call a couple of weeks ago from the presbytery’s nominating committee. It didn’t come as a surprise that the committee would ask me to serve a second 3-year-term on the Commission of Ministry. But I was tired. And all I could think of was how on earth can I possibly keep on serving in this challenging labor for the vineyard that is the Presbytery of Long Island? When I feel so humbled and often unprepared for the work that we do?

I have been reading a book by Louisa Woosley. Does her name mean anything to you? She wrote and self-published Shall Woman Preach? Or The Question Answered in 1891. She writes in her introduction, “I am not insensible to the criticism to which this little volume may be subjected. I claim no perfection, in either the style or matter of the composition, as I make no pretension to scholarship. My chief aim has been to present biblical truths in such a form that the anxious inquirers after truth may be better able to understand the commands and will of God representing the much disputed question of the ordination of women.”[1]

This uneducated woman was truly ahead of her time. On this day when we recognize and give thanks for the reformers of the Church who led the way to change in faith and practice, it is fitting to tell the story of the first female minister ordained in an American Presbyterian Church. Louisa’s call to ministry was not without opposition and controversy. She wrote her book in the hopes that her readers would “lay aside any preconceived notions and give this investigation an honest hearing.”[2]

Louisa was born in the hills of central Kentucky on March 24, 1862. Her father was a longtime member of a Baptist church and served for many years as its clerk. In 1874 when she was 12, Louisa attended a Baptist revival meeting and was “led by the Spirit to seek the atoning merits of Christ’s blood…When all was laid upon God’s altar,” she says, it pleased the Lord to accept the offering, pardon her offenses, and save from sin and guilt. She had peace with God and was sealed by the Holy Spirit. She was made to rejoice in her salvation.[3] Soon after, she heard God’s call to work in the vineyard, “seeing the harvest was truly plenteous and the laborers few.” But then she talked herself out of answering the call, feeling insufficient in her abilities, being uneducated and young, and the wrong gender. She had never even heard of a “lady preacher” before. “And knowing that there would be opposition,” she says, “I tried to persuade myself that it was not right for women to preach.”[4]

When Louisa was 18, on Feb. 20, 1879, she married Curtis Woosley, a farmer and member of the Macedonia Cumberland Presbyterian Church outside Caneyville, Kentucky. She hoped to persuade Curtis to enter the ministry so she could become a minister’s wife. “This I failed to do,” she says. She sunk into depression, and was stirred to read her Bible carefully, marking all the places where a woman was mentioned. From these notes, she wrote her book, hoping, she says, “to bless the world,” by helping other women decide to “work for the Master.”[5] In the summer of 1883, she finished her reading of the Bible from Genesis through Revelation and like many of the Church reformers in the 14th, 15th and 16th centuries, she was a changed person upon reading God’s word for herself in her own language. “I was now convinced of the fact that God, being no respecter of persons, had not overlooked the women, but that he had a great work for them to do.” At the same time, she felt, “Woe is unto me if I preach not the gospel.”[6]

With her own unrealized call, her depression deepened. She prayed that the Lord would restore the joy of her salvation and promised to work for God if the Lord would lift her spirits. God did restore her joy, only to have her question her calling, once again. “The people will not hear me,” she argued with God. “And I cannot get any work to go, and my husband will not be willing to let me go.” Then she had two children and more excuses why she shouldn’t follow God’s call—her two children needed all her care and attention. And then her little girl fell gravely ill. The physician told her that her child was beyond the hope of recovery. Heartbroken, she pleaded with God and tried to make a bargain with the Lord. We do that sometimes, don’t we? She promised to preach the gospel if God would heal her child.  Miraculously, her daughter was healed. Still, she was unwilling to go. She fell ill and was confined to her room for six months. “Though unable to raise myself in bed,” she says, “I laid myself, my husband, and two dear children upon God’s altar, and with all my heart, I said, ‘Oh Lord, lead me in a plain path, and show me thy way, that I may walk therein.’ By faith I put my hand in his, as he reached out to help me, and thus far he has led me even all the way.’”[7]

Our Ephesians reading today is one that was often quoted during the Reformations of the 15th and 16th centuries. We are different now, the letter says. We have a changed state, a before and after the work of God’s grace. We were dead in our sin and trespasses, and following the passions of the world and the ruler of the air—Satan himself. All of us lived in that fallen state. No one was without sin before “God, who is rich in mercy, out of the great love with which he loved us even when we were dead through our trespasses, made us alive together with Christ.” Who is this God who loved us first, when we were dead in our sins? This is a God who did the work for us that we were unable to do for ourselves.

Here comes the part that spoke to the reformers in the 15th and 16th centuries, “by grace you have been saved through faith,” and even our faith is a gift and not of our own doing. In this changed state, as the people of God who have been forgiven and freed from sin, we still hold ourselves back from living in the full freedom of the redeemed. We hold onto our insecurities and past failures and come up with excuses, like Louisa did. We are busy, we are tired, or the work will be too hard, and we might not be good enough, smart enough, or strong enough to do it.

Well, I did call the presbytery nominating committee chair back. I told her that after serving three years on the Commission for Ministry, I know how challenging and consuming the work can be. And yet I feel a passion to help churches going through pastoral transitions. I feel compassion for flocks without a shepherd. And I have enjoyed getting to know and encourage new ministers in our presbytery, particularly the women, who have unique challenges, especially when they are the first female minister to serve their congregations.

Our church’s nominating committee will soon be seeking out new leadership for our church to begin serving in 2027. You will have an opportunity to nominate other active members to serve as deacons, trustees, and elders. But if you have never served the Lord through a leadership role here or it has been a long time since you served, I pray you will be inspired by the story of Louisa Woosley. Louisa, in her testimony, shares how she held herself back from the full life in Christ that God wanted her to live. She didn’t find peace and joy until she put aside all her excuses and fears and said yes to God’s unique call for her, though it meant she was breaking through a glass ceiling.

Louisa’s chance to preach came on January 1, 1887, when a minister didn’t show at a small Caneyville church.  The Session, knowing her deep knowledge of the Bible, asked her to lead worship on New Year’s Day. “And for the first time in life I went to the sacred desk and opened my mouth for God,” she says. “Oh, that was a precious hour—a green spot in my memory. My sky was without a cloud, so happy was I in the discharge of duty. I felt that the days of darkness were past, and that God’s approval rested upon my labors.” In the next four years, she faced strong opposition, which also came from her Baptist father. She persevered and preached 912 sermons in those 4 years, received 2000 professions of faith, and wrote a book arguing that denying women the right to preach also denied the Holy Spirit. In fall 1887, she was received by the Nolin Presbytery as a candidate for ministry in the Cumberland Presbyterian denomination. In November 1888, she was licensed to preach. In November 1889, she was ordained by Nolin Presbytery to the full work of gospel ministry.

But there would continue to be obstacles to overcome. Kentucky Synod denied her election by her presbytery to serve as an alternate delegate to the 1894 General Assembly and essentially revoked her ordination. Nolin Presbytery fought for her and didn’t win. The presbytery was forced to remove her name from the minister rolls. But they didn’t lose, either, for they allowed her to continue as a minister, anyway. Three years later, she was elected to serve as Stated Clerk of Leitchfield Presbytery. She held that office for 25 years. Eventually, her ordination would be restored. She went on to serve as a commissioner to General Assembly three times and was elected moderator to the Kentucky Synod in 1938, when she was 76. Her husband had died in 1930, and she spent the final 20 years of her life with her daughter in Lexington, KY. She went home to be with her Lord in 1952. She was 90 years old.

Dear friends, do you know the works that God wants you to do? You who were created in Christ Jesus for good works that God has ordained? Don’t let your fears or fatigue or insecurities hold you back. The reward is a great peace that surpasses all understanding and a joy that cannot be described in knowing that you are in God’s will and trusting in the Son.

I said yes to the nominating committee to serve another three years on COM, not knowing what God has planned. But knowing that the God who called me to this work, the Lord who created me in Christ for good works, will not fail to strengthen and guide me every step of the way.

Some say that by today’s standards, Louisa Woosley really wasn’t the radical reformer one might assume. “She was very much a product of late nineteenth-century American culture. While her style of life did not reflect the accepted role for women of her day, Louisa continued to exalt motherhood as a worthy vocation for a woman’s life and appealed to woman’s superior moral influence in the home as a reasonable defense of women’s activity in the religious sphere.”[8]

“Mrs. Woosley,” says one tribute, “filled the pulpit with grace and dignity. She was a small, attractive, modestly dressed woman. With her culture, charm and knowledge of the Bible and God’s plans for saving souls she was an inspiration to all who heard her.” In her 50 years of ministry, she preached 6,343 sermons, heard 7,664 professions of faith, and presided over 258 baptisms.[9] During her later years, she preached less and taught more, devoting herself to her Ladies’ Bible Class at First Methodist Church of Lexington. With love and loyalty, she was ever true to her own church.”[10] And in many homes of the nation will be found the little book published by Mrs. Woosley in 1891, “Shall Woman Preach?”

Let us pray. Holy One, we give you thanks for your grace, for loving us while we were dead in our sins and for sending your Son to give his life and to raise us to be alive together with him. Today, on Reformation Sunday, we give thanks for our ancestors who acted courageously and took risks to follow the Spirit and lead Your Church into a better, more faithful and just place. Thank you for your Word, which continues to draw us nearer to you and equip us to do the good works that you have ordained for us. Lord, we ask for strength, unity, and peace for your Church around the world; may all the walls that divide us be brought down. We pray that more leaders would be raised up to preach and minister boldly, and with your grace and love, welcome others warmly into your fold. And finally, Lord, stir us to heed your call without excuses or complaints, for the harvest is plenteous, as Louisa Woosley said, and the laborers are few. In Christ we pray. Amen.


[1] Louisa M. Woosley, Shall Woman Preach or The Question Answered (CA: Frontier Press, 1989 and 2018), 6.

[2] Louisa M. Woosley, Shall Woman Preach? 6.

[3] Louisa M. Woosley, Shall Woman Preach? 96.

[4] Louisa M. Woosley, Shall Woman Preach? 96.

[5] Louisa M. Woosley, Shall Woman Preach? 97.

[6] Louisa M. Woosley, Shall Woman Preach? 97.

[7] Louisa M. Woosley, Shall Woman Preach? 98.

[8] https://www.cumberland.org/hfcpc/minister/woosleyL.htm

[9] https://www.thearda.com/us-religion/history/timelines/entry?etype=5&eid=100

[10] https://www.cumberland.org/hfcpc/minister/woosleyL.htm

“Show me the money”

Meditation on Matthew 22:15-22

First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown, NY

Rev. Dr. Karen Crawford

Oct. 18, 2026

I visited Tom Deakins at St. Catherine’s Hospital last Sunday. He had been hospitalized with symptoms of a stroke, but the MRI machine had been broken for the first anxious days of his stay. Finally, the machine had been repaired, but he was still waiting his turn for the scans and other necessary tests that would hopefully lead to diagnosis and treatment. His wife, Marci, and two of their adult daughters were waiting and worrying and so tired of waiting and worrying about what was going on or not going on or what the next steps would be.

I listened, and we held hands and prayed. After we hugged goodbye and as I made my way back to my car, I thought about how important the timing is for our pastoral visits. What seems random to us, looking back, was all part of God’s plan. The Blessing of the Animals was, sadly, going to be rained out that day, and I was being sent to be the peaceful presence of Christ when it was most needed for Tom and his family. Of course, I didn’t know any of this before I arrived.

This is truly our highest calling, my friends, as followers of the Living Christ—to walk beside those going through difficult times and offer a gentle, listening ear, encouragement, love, and prayer. This is what makes us different from the secular, transactional world around us that values money and possessions over all things. We offer the presence, hope, love, and grace of Christ and our heartfelt prayers, no strings attached. We expect nothing in return.

This offering of ourselves to our neighbors in need is the context in which we are studying a passage about stewardship from Matthew’s gospel today. We bring our own context to the Scripture, and as our context changes, our own understanding and application of the Scripture changes, too. Today, I am seeing new things in this familiar story that includes that unforgettable but sometimes misunderstood quote, “Give therefore to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s and to God the things that are God’s.”

Matthew tells us from the beginning that the Pharisees and the Herodians, a political faction of wealthy elites who were pro-Roman and supported the Herodian dynasty, are plotting to entrap Jesus. They are in the temple courtyard, with an audience listening in. These two groups have come together in their mutual dislike and fear of Jesus, who is growing in popularity with the masses. They are hoping to force him to say that it IS or ISN’T lawful to pay taxes “to Caesar.”

If he says it IS lawful, this would be a betrayal to his faith community, which was being overwhelmed by a complex, multi-layered system of oppressive civil (Roman and Herodian) and religious taxes. The coins are seen as pagan and idolatrous by the Jewish community and viewed with animosity; they feature Caesar’s head with a laurel wreath and suggest that he is a god, with the saying, “Tiberius Caesar, Son of the Divine Augustus.”

Historians estimate that Judeans are paying 30% to 60% of their total income or production. They have Roman imperial indirect taxes, such as customs duties, road tolls, bridge fees, and market taxes collected at ports, city gates, and major trade routes. They have a corrupt tax collection system, “where private contractors or publicans bid for a region’s franchise. These collectors (make) a profit by extracting far more than the official Roman rate and using extortion, threats, or inflated property values.”[1] They have local and regional taxes, as well, paid to client kings and governors, such as Herod Antipas or Roman prefects, such as Pontius Pilate, who “levied local infrastructure, court, and building taxes to finance grand architectural projects, including the expansion of the Temple Mount and palaces.” They have religious taxes, too, as every adult Jewish male is required by Exodus 30 to pay an annual half-shekel to support the operations of the Second Temple in Jerusalem.”[2] And they have Roman imperial direct taxes, such as the tributum soli (a land and agricultural property tax) and the tributum capitis (a poll or head tax levied on individuals). This poll or head tax is what is being debated here.

But even better than forcing Jesus to say that it IS lawful to pay the poll taxes to Caesar is to trick him into saying that it isn’t lawful, so they can arrest him for treason.

Jesus responds aggressively to the attempt at entrapment. “You hypocrites!” he says, not being fooled by their false flattery and manipulation. “Why are YOU putting ME to the test?” Then, my favorite part. “Show me the money,” he says. And it dawns on me for the first time, after seeing this passage countless times. This isn’t just an object lesson or an attempt at distraction. Jesus doesn’t have any of these idolatrous coins in his pocket! By his asking for them to produce one, he is revealing just how hypocritical they are!

And now for the most important part of the passage. What exactly does Jesus mean, after asking them whose head is on the coin, by, “Give therefore to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s and to God the things that are God’s?”  He has come up with a trick answer to the trick question. And that’s why the Pharisees and Herodians are amazed by what he says.

Some people take this to mean that there is a way to separate our money and possessions into two categories, some that belong to Caesar and some that belong to God. Or that the Lord doesn’t really care about what we do with our money; money is something worldly and not spiritual and therefore doesn’t matter for eternity.

But that would be far from the truth. That’s not what Jesus means here.  In the Old Testament, dozens of Proverbs and other scriptures speak about faithful attitudes toward money and giving, such as Proverbs 22:9, “A generous man will be blessed” and Proverbs 15:27, “A greedy man brings trouble to his family.” In fact, Jesus spoke about money, wealth, and possessions more than almost any other topic, devoting about 15% of his recorded words and 16 of 38 of his parables to the topic of money.[3]  For example, let us recall when Jesus startles a would-be follower in Mark 10, who asks what he must do to inherit eternal life. Jesus tells the man to sell all that he has and give his money to the poor. And then, follow him. But the man goes away sadly, unwilling to part with his great wealth.

The key to understanding this passage in Matthew is through contemplating what Jesus means when he tells us to give to God “the things that are God’s.” I ask you, “What things belong to God?” And, “What things don’t belong to God?”

Psalm 24:1 declares, “The earth is the Lord’s and the fullness thereof, the world and those who dwell within.” My friends, we belong to God. All that we are. All that we will become. All our gifts and possessions have been given to us for God’s loving purposes!

After these last couple of weeks of pastoral care to members of our flock with serious health issues, and caring for my husband, struggling with severe back pain, I have to say that it is comforting to consider that we belong to God in every way. God cares for you and me! We are not alone in our struggles! Knowing that we cannot separate the things of God and our faith from the things of anything else in this world brings me peace. Worrying about money and seeking to accumulate possessions is a hindrance to the calling that we have been given as the Body of Christ to shine light into darkness and reveal the Lord’s goodness and healing to a broken world.

Dear friends, you have such compassion and generosity, never hesitating to offer yourselves—all your gifts, including your time and talents and even cooking—to those in need—including Jim and me! We are so grateful for your kind words and fervent prayers. They have given us strength when we have felt weak and vulnerable.

This is truly our highest calling as followers of the Living Christ—to walk beside those going through difficult times and offer a gentle, listening ear, encouragement, love, and prayer. This is what makes us different from the transactional world around us that values money and possessions above all things. We offer the presence, hope, love, and grace of Christ and our heartfelt prayers, no strings attached. We expect nothing in return. Our treasure is in heaven, Amen?

Marci and Tom are grateful for your kindness, as well. They reached out yesterday with a letter for their church family and asked me to share it with you.

“First, Tom and I would like to thank everyone who offered prayers, concern, and help during Tom’s recent health crisis,” Marci says. “As many of you know, Tom was hospitalized the day after we returned from vacation with symptoms of a stroke.  Many tests later, a stroke was ruled out, although several other medical conditions came to light, which in combination led to his symptoms. With treatment, including minor surgery, he is at home, well on the way to recovery. Again, our sincere gratitude for your prayers, thoughts and support.  We know that they were a large part of the positive outcome he is experiencing. With much love and appreciation, Tom and Marci Deakins.”

Let us pray.

God of All Comfort, thank you for the ways that you provide for our needs through the Body of Christ—our friends and family. Thank you for having a good plan for us and for being faithful to use us for your loving purposes. Thank you for leading us to bring your Son’s peace to our brothers and sisters who are hurting or otherwise needy and for granting us the power to reveal your comfort, love, mercy, and grace to those most vulnerable around us. Watch over and keep our flock in your tender care, dear Lord. Give us courage to live into our calling as followers of your Son, the Living Christ, to walk compassionately beside those going through difficult times and listen gently, encourage, love, and pray. Lead us to be your light in darkness, your healing in a broken world. Amen.


[1] Alan D. Campbell, “Monetary System, Taxation, and Publicans in the Time of Christ” in Accounting Historians Journal, vol. 13, issue 2, fall 1986, accessed Oct. 17, 2026, at https://egrove.olemiss.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1276&context=aah_journal.

[2] Jerry Boyer, “Jesus, the Temple Tax, and Fourfold Atonement,” Feb. 16, 2021, accessed Oct. 17, 2026, at https://theopolisinstitute.com/jesus-the-temple-tax-and-four-fold-atonement/

[3] https://support.envoyfinancial.com/bible-verses-about-money-and-stewardship/

Art by Stushie, used with permission

“And the God of Peace will be with you

First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown”

Meditation on Philippians 4:1-9

Rev. Dr. Karen Crawford

Oct. 11, 2026

 Dolly Parton is no longer with us. She went home to the Lord on August 25 after a brief battle with cancer. She was just 80 years old.

I was shocked to hear of her passing as many people were and still are. Tributes continue to be shared by those struggling with grief and overwhelmed by gratitude for the gift of her life. They all say how much she and her music and acts of kindness and generosity meant to them, even people who had never met her.

That was Dolly to a T. You couldn’t see her perform or give an interview without being moved by her candor, warmth, and joy. You always had the feeling that she cared about people. And that if you did meet her, she would care about you, too. She had a gentle way about her and always a smile. And yes, she was funny and known for her self-deprecating sense of humor. Whenever she was asked about her glamorous, rhinestone-sparkling appearance, she would say, “It takes a lot of money to look this cheap!” She didn’t mind jokes about her well-endowed body, either. On receiving an honorary doctorate in 2009 from the University of Tennessee, she said, “Just think, I am Dr. Dolly! So when people say something about ‘Double-D,’ they will be thinking of something entirely different.”

Her desire to be a star that started from an early age “wasn’t the most obvious career path,” given her simple beginnings. The word “rural” doesn’t quite capture her Smoky Mountain upbringing in Locust Ridge, TN, in the 1950s. The daughter of an illiterate sharecropper, her parents and their 12 children lived in a small one or two-room log cabin. No electricity. No running water. No car. Her musical talent and her faith were nurtured at an early age. Uncle Bill Owens taught her to play guitar. When somebody came for a visit, her mama would tell her, “Run and get your guitar and sing that song” for whoever just arrived. She sang gospel, country, bluegrass, and blues. “Life, love, broken hearts, God, poverty, family, and moonshine,” she says, “we sang about it all.” She composed and sang her own songs from the age of 5, when she sang about her corncob doll, “Little Tiny Tasseltop.”

The 11-time Grammy and other award-winning singer, songwriter, actress, and philanthropist was proud of the world she grew up in. She never forgot her home, family, or community. Her Imagination Library has distributed more than 300 million free books so far, beginning with preschoolers in her own Sevier County. Her foundation awards a $15,000 scholarship each year to a senior in every high school in the county. She gave $1 million toward a new hospital in her county. And when massive fires swept through her county in 2016, destroying homes of more than 1,000 families, she asked her foundation to give $1,000 a month for 6 months to each family who lost their primary residence; the total gift came to $12 million.

Dolly wasn’t shy about speaking of her faith. It wasn’t the same kind of faith that her grandfather, a “hellfire-and-brimstone Pentecostal preacher,” had. But “I’m still very much a believer,” she said recently, “and always have been, of course.” She often talked about plain conversations that she had with God, and how she prayed before every performance and when she was working on her music in nature. “God is my co-writer and my co-pilot,” she said. “I sit under trees to write songs. I listen to God’s voice through the wind.”

While there is much to admire about Dolly, I am particularly impressed by her popularity with so many people and her gift of getting along with everybody, even those with whom she had had disagreements. One of her blockbuster hits, sung by Whitney Houston in the movie, My Body Guard, was written for Porter Wagoner. Porter had given Dolly, in 1967, her first big chance when he invited her to be the “girl singer” on his syndicated TV series, “The Porter Wagoner Show.” There came a time, in 1974, when the generation gap between their musical styles became increasingly obvious. They began to butt heads over the songs she would sing and how she would sing them. She was ready to move on to a solo career. But he didn’t want to let her go. So, she wrote him a song called, “I Will Always Love You.”

If I should stay
I would only be in your way
So I’ll go, but I know
I’ll think of you each step of the way
And I will always love you
I will always love you

Bitter-sweet memories
That’s all I am taking with me
Goodbye, please don’t cry
We both know that I’m not
What you need

And I will always love you
I will always love you

Paul wasn’t an award-winning musician back in his day. But this letter written for his beloved church at Phillipi, mourning their loss of him while he is in jail, fearing he is a goner, is a beautiful poem that would be a lovely song, if someone were to put it to music, especially verses 4 through 9. I can’t tell you how many people have told me that this is the passage that has helped through many a hard time.

I realized this week, when studying this passage, that we often skip over the first three verses of chapter four. Yet they are so terribly relevant for the church of Jesus Christ in any age. Paul mentions two women by name. And you know how seldom women are named in the Bible. They must be important for him and well known to the church to name them, and then we learn that they have been mission coworkers with him. Listen to how he asks others to help them resolve what sounds like a bitter conflict.

 He has talked about his love for them, Christ’s love for them, and their love for him and Christ from the first line of this letter. But now he gets to the meat of his lesson on love when he explains how love behaves. He inserts, in the middle of his beautiful poem, “I urge Euodia and I urge Syntyche to be of the same mind in the Lord. Yes, and I ask you also, my loyal companion, help these women, for they have struggled beside me in the work of the gospel, together with Clement and the rest of my coworkers, whose names are in the book of life.”

We are left wondering what the conflict is all about. It might not be a theological conflict at all; but rather it seems to be personal. After all, Euodia and Syntyche’s names, together with Clement and the rest of Paul’s co-workers, are written in the book of life. This might be a reference to Revelation and those who are freed from condemnation in the final judgment.

Paul’s answer to personal conflict between his coworkers for the gospel? To be “of the same mind in the Lord.” We can’t do this in our own selves, alone. We all need help from the Spirit and one another. The mind of Christ stirs us to act in loving ways. The song builds to a crescendo.  

“Finally, brothers and sisters, whatever is true, whatever is honorable, whatever is just, whatever is pure, whatever is pleasing, whatever is commendable, if there is any excellence and if there is anything worthy of praise, think about these things. As for the things that you have learned and received and heard and noticed in me, do them, and the God of peace will be with you.”

Since Dolly’s passing, I have learned new things about her. I didn’t know that she had endometriosis in the mid 1980s, and because of it, she could not have children. This led to a bout of severe depression. She kept her depression a secret for a long time. Later on, she talked about it to help remove the stigma of mental illness and let others know that they are not alone in their suffering. She said that she relied heavily on prayer and close friends to help her through it. Then, in the last year of her life, she neglected her own health, while caring for her husband of 60 years. Knowing that she overlooked her own health problems while caring for Carl Dean, who died in March 2025, makes her seem even more real to me.

Something else that I learned about Dolly is that she recorded a secret song in 2015 called “My Place in History,” and locked it inside a time capsule at her resort. The wooden box, made by her Uncle Bill, won’t be opened until 2046—on Dolly’s 100th birthday. She never felt good about locking up a song that “nobody was going to hear ‘til then,” she said. “And I tell you, you have no idea how that has bothered me. I want to go dig that up so bad.” 

I don’t know about you, but I am pretty sure that “My Place in History” will never eclipse the popularity of “I Will Always Love You.” Every time I hear the song—and I hope this will happen for you now, as well— I think of how God has placed good people in our lives who are sometimes hard to love, such as Euodia and Syntyche—good and faithful people, colaborers with Paul, who had a personal conflict. The important thing to remember is the promise, if we live in loving ways, as Paul teaches us to do. “And the God of peace will be with you.”

I hope life treats you kind
And I hope that you have all
That you ever dreamed of
And I wish you joy
And happiness
But above all of this
I wish you love


And I will always love you
I will always love you

I will always love you.

Let us pray.

God of peace, help us to love those who are sometimes hard to love, to have grace for one another, as you have unconditional love and unfathomable grace for us. Teach us how to control our thought patterns, as Paul teaches us. Thank you for all that you have done for us through your Son and that our names are written in the Lamb’s Book of Life. Thank you that we will never lose our salvation, and for your promise of everlasting presence with us as we seek to live out our faith through gentle, loving ways, rejoicing at all times, and turning our worries into prayer. Help us to hear your voice in nature, like Dolly did, through the wind. In Christ we pray. Amen.

The First Christian Community

Meditation on Acts 2:37-47

Rev. Dr. Karen Crawford

First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown

World Communion Sunday

Oct. 4, 2026

Art by Stushie for World Communion Sunday, used with permission

We don’t know the exact day or even the season when the first church is organized in Smithtown. No records remain concerning its formation. But historians believe that the year is 1675. And that the first church is this church.

A year ago, we celebrated our 350th anniversary.  We gathered for worship in the afternoon to rededicate ourselves and our 200-year-old sanctuary for God’s loving purposes. We invited local and state dignitaries; synod and presbytery leaders; former pastors and their families; and all our members, past and present. After worship, we shared a special meal. That celebration has now become part of our history that I feel led to share today.

Nine years have passed in 1675 since English immigrant Richard Smith receives the clear title to the lands comprising Smith’s Town.[1] Smith had come to the New World with a tide of religious refugees seeking freedom from persecution, land to farm, and a community in which to raise their children to live out their dreams. Smith’s church in 1675 is more like a family chapel. The little wooden meeting house is built on a frontier settlement on a rise of a hill off a dirt wagon path, where Moriches and Nissequogue River roads intersect.[2]

 Smith and his family are Congregationalists, free to govern their churches and worship as they choose without interference from a higher church authority. Congregational churches had been in existence on Long Island for 25 years in 1675, but only one Presbyterian Church had been founded—in Jamaica three years before at the western end of Long Island.[3] The first presbytery, the Presbytery of Philadelphia, would be formed in 1706, followed by the Synod of Philadelphia in 1717. The first General Assembly would be called more than a century after our congregation was founded—in 1789, after the Revolutionary War, with the creation of a national Church, the Presbyterian Church in the United States of America.

There aren’t enough pastors in the 1600s and 1700s for every Congregational church on Long Island, and little money to pay them. Smith’s family and neighbors solve the problem by sharing pastors with the Congregational Church of Setauket in the early years. The first minister is probably Nathaniel Brewster, who serves Setauket from 1665 to 1690.[4] Brewster is among the first graduation class of 9 men from Harvard College. Our first recorded minister is shared with Setauket, as well, beginning in 1697; he is George Phillips, another Harvard grad.[5] Richard Smith passes away in 1692, but his children and their families and neighbors continue to gather at the meeting house.[6] Finally, the church is able to call its first resident minister in 1712—a 28-year-old Yale grad named Daniel Taylor, who takes on a second job as the town clerk. Another pastor, Abner Reeve, is called to serve the flock at the meeting house in 1735. The 25-year-old Yale grad is from Southold, Long Island.[7]

 The little flock joins the Suffolk Presbytery a few years later, though some members are reluctant to give up their Congregationalist leanings. In 1750, they sense the Lord leading them to a new mission field. The business center of the Town, which had grown to about 700 people, had evolved in our present general location. So, the little wooden building is dismantled and reassembled here on donated land from Obadiah and Epenetus Smith.[8] The flock in 1750 numbers just 7 people, who, at the time, don’t have a resident pastor. They are in one of those uncomfortable interim periods, like the ones we weathered in the 2oth and 21st centuries. Naphtali Daggett, a 1748 Yale grad who would be ordained here in September 1751, dedicates the rebuilt Church. The seven members are Obadiah Smith, Susannah Smith, George Phillips, Elizabeth Phillips, William Saxton, Dorcas Saxton, and Mary Blydenburgh.[9] It is an act of hope and faith for the fledgling congregation. Soon after the relocation, 14 more people join, including a man named Peter with no last name, an African American who may have been brought here as a slave in his youth.[10]

The congregation has tough times ahead. The early years of the church’s second century are characterized by political turmoil.[11] The colonists are defeated in the Battle of Long Island. The entire island falls under British military rule in 1776. Some residents flee across the Sound to Connecticut. Those who stay are harassed by British troops. These troops help themselves to 6,396 feet of lumber from our meeting house and from the fencing and horse sheds on the property.[12] And our minister from 1774 to 1787, the outspoken patriot Joshua Hartt, a Princeton grad, is fired on by a British soldier during worship, but is miraculously unharmed. He is arrested and placed in British prisons on several occasions.[13]

 By 1797, the church is struggling. Session records say that the congregation is “destitute of a pastor and … in a deranged and broken situation.”[14] The Presbytery advises the divided church to draw up a covenant that each member would sign. And they do. The congregation promises to “watch over one another in the Love of the Lord and give up (themselves and theirs) to the discipline of the Church, according to the direction of Christ.”[15] They promise to “hold Communion with each other in the Word of God, and in the careful and diligent Use of the Ordinance of Jesus Christ, so long as (they) continue together in this relation(ship) by the Grace of God.”[16] Disagreement continues between factions in the congregation in 1810, this time, over the use of the meeting house. Caleb Smith, President of the Board of Trustees, orders that “no person be permitted to enter without permission.”[17] The following year, in 1811, a new minister, Bradford Marcy, comes to serve Smithtown and Babylon concurrently. During his pastorate, Articles of Agreement are drawn up reuniting dissenting members.[18]

 In 1823, the congregation votes to build a new church. The Trustees have $1,410 for that purpose,[19] and the builder will be George Curtiss. The old meeting house is put up for sale at public auction.[20] The flock waits two years after their new house of worship is finished in 1825—till all the debts have cleared—before this building is dedicated for a holy use.[21] Ithmar Pillsbury, a minister representative of the presbytery, presides over the service on Sept. 9, 1827, because the church is, once again, without a resident pastor.[22] It is another act of hope and faith for the now 32 members.[23] With the new building, the pastoral leadership of the Rev. Pillsbury, installed in 1830, the congregation’s outreach, and by the grace of God, the church grows by 52 new members, and will rise again in 1840, under a new pastor’s leadership. Many old Smithtown names are recorded at this time: Smith, Blydenburgh, Wheeler, Miller, Mills, Hallock, Arthur, Saxton, Hawkins, Conkling, Davis, Wood, Vail, Bailey.[24]

 As we consider our beginnings as a congregation, and our persevering in hope and faith in God’s grace, it is good to recall the powerful Spirit that formed the first ever Church of Jesus Christ. This is the story from Acts that we hear today, on World Communion Sunday, as we celebrate the Spirit that continues to empower and connect all of Christ’s churches around the world.

The Spirit that comes on Pentecost as tongues of fire equips Christ’s followers to share the gospel with worshipers from many nations who had come to Jerusalem for Shavuot or the Feast of Weeks. The Spirit leads Peter to deliver a sermon that cuts to the heart of his hearers. Convicted, they ask him what they must do to be saved. Peter, as John the Baptist preached by the Jordan, tells them to repent and be baptized. But this is a new kind of baptism. This one, he says, is “in the name of Jesus Christ so that your sins may be forgiven,” and to receive “the gift of the Holy Spirit.” The promise of the Spirit is for those being baptized AND their “children, and for all who are far away, everyone,” says Peter, “whom the Lord our God calls to him.” About three thousand people are added to the Church that day. Three thousand! And all the new Christians devote themselves to the apostles’ teaching and to fellowship, to the breaking of bread, and the prayers.

What touches my heart is the “awe” that comes upon everyone “because many wonders and signs were being done through the apostles.” Retaining that sense of awe and wonder in what the Lord is doing in our midst can be a challenge for us if we get bogged down in the weeds of day-to-day ministry, such as the ever-present worries of fixing our aging building and paying the bills. But maybe the problem lies with our faith and not our resources.  New believers in the first Church held onto things loosely; they didn’t hesitate to share their possessions and goods or sell them and distribute the proceeds when there was a need. Worship was a priority and not just once a week. They worshiped “day by day,” spending much time together in the temple. They broke bread in each other’s homes and ate with “glad and generous hearts, praising God and having the goodwill of all the people.” And the Lord blessed them for their faithfulness. “Day by day the Lord added to their number those who were being saved.”

 Dear friends, the Spirit who was with our ancestors is with us still. Our call to love and serve God and neighbor has never changed, though Smithtown hardly resembles the tiny, pioneer town it once was. May we leap like a deer over every obstacle and weather every storm like an oak tree. May we never forget where we came from—a family chapel in a little wooden meeting house on the rise of a hill, off a dirt wagon path, where Moriches and Nissequogue River roads intersect. May we embrace our history but never get stuck in the past. May we forgive one another and dwell in peace during times of uncomfortable transitions and uncertainty. May we retain our sense of awe and wonder in what the Lord is doing in our midst. May we lean into our future with courage, hope, faith, and God’s grace. And may we remember that WE and not the building are God’s house, a holy temple, and servants of our Master Lord.

Let us pray.

Holy God, we thank you for the centuries of ministry we have experienced here in the name of your Risen Son, for the promise of transformation through baptism, and your Spirit that continues to lead and empower us. Thank you for all your beloved children who have come before us—the thousands who joined the first Church on Pentecost and the thousands who have worshiped here over the centuries, loving one another, serving you and this community, planting and watering seeds, and praying for growth. Lord, fill us with your awe and wonder and help us overcome the challenges of day-to-day ministry. Guide us into the future with courage, hope, faith, and grace. Amen.


      [1] J. Richard Mehalick, Church and Community: 1675-1975, the Story of the First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown, NY (Second Edition, 2010), 17.

      [2] Mehalick, 23.

      [3] Mehalick, 16. 

     [4] Mehalick, 17.

     [5] Mehalick, 18.

     [6] Mehalick, 17.

     [7] Mehalick, 19.

     [8] Mehalick, 27.

     [9] Mehalick, 28.

    [10] Mehalick, 28.

    [11] Mehalick, 45.

     [12]Mehalick, 46.

     [13] Mehalick, 46.

     [14] Mehalick, 46.

     [15] Mehalick, 47.

     [16] Mehalick, 47.

     [17] Mehalick, 56.

     [18] Mehalick, 56.

     [19] Mehalick, 58.

     [20] Mehalick, 76.

     [21] Mehalick, 58.

     [22] Mehalick, 58.

     [23] Mehalick, 59.

     [24] Mehalick, 60.

Come, Labor On! Well done! Well done!

Meditation on Matthew 20:1-16

Rev. Dr. Karen Crawford

First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown, NY

Commissioning the Choirs and Welcoming New Members

Sept. 27, 2026

Stushie Art, used with permission

Do animals have morals? What do you think? Maybe it depends on the animals.

I listened to an NPR/TED Talk yesterday with that title, “Do animals have morals?” “Empathy, cooperation, and fairness seem like distinctly human traits,” says the teaser. “But biologist Frans de Waal explains why… animals might share those same qualities.”[1] DeWaal is a professor of psychology at Emory University, director of the Living Links Center at the Yerkes National Primate Center, and author of Chimpanzee Politics, Our Inner Ape, Primates and Philosophers, The Bonobo and the Atheist, and other publications.

In his lecture from Sept. 2014, DeWaal discusses research with chimpanzees on what he calls the pillars of morality: reciprocity, fairness, empathy, and compassion. In a study of prosocial behavior in animals, buckets of tokens are placed in front of two chimpanzees in separate cages. If the first chimp gives the researcher a red token, then only they are fed, and not the other chimp. If the chimp gives a green token, then both chimps are fed. What color do you think the chimps choose overwhelmingly? They prefer the prosocial green over the red so that both chimps are fed.

Later DeWaal shows a video of two capuchin monkeys in a well-known fairness study to show that animals can perceive an inequity. Two capuchins in side-by-side cages can see what the other is eating. They are trained to give the researcher a stone to receive a reward of a cucumber or a grape. When both are given cucumber, they are happy to eat it 25 times in a row. But when they deliberately create an inequality and give one cucumber and the other a grape, what happens? The one who receives cucumber after the other receives a grape gets mad and throws it back at the researcher. They yell and throw a temper tantrum and pull on the door to try to get to the grapes. In another test, two groups of monkeys do the same task, but receive unequal rewards. When the monkeys are asked to do the same task again, the ones who received the lesser reward refuse to do it. The researcher’s conclusion? Even monkeys reject unequal pay.

People have always been sensitive about unequal pay—going back to ancient times. We find it here when Jesus shares a parable about the Kingdom of God in our reading in Matthew.  A landowner goes out to the marketplace at different times of the day, beginning early in the morning, and hires groups of workers for his vineyard. The first group is promised a denarius for a day’s work, which is typical for that time and place. I remember my grandfather, who was born in 1888, saying each night, “Another day, another dollar.” Have you heard that saying before? It must go back to ancient times. But then the landowner goes out at 9, noon, 3, and 5 and hires more workers. “Why are you standing here idle all day?” he asks those at 5. They say to him, “Because no one has hired us.” He invites them to work without telling them their pay. When evening comes, the owner tells the manager to pay everyone the same—one denarius, promised to the earliest group there at sunrise. The manager must start with those who have only been working since 5 p.m. When the first group is paid last, they think that they will receive more than one denarius, because they have been working the longest and hardest of all. It’s only fair, right? But they only receive what they had been promised at sunrise—one denarius. How do they feel when they receive it, though it is fair pay for a day’s wages?  They grumble against the landowner, saying, “‘These last worked only one hour, and you have made them equal to us who have borne the burden of the day and the scorching heat.’” The landowner responds, “Am I not allowed to do what I choose with what belongs to me? Or are you envious because I am generous?”

This is such an interesting picture of the work of the Kingdom. The reward is the same for all who accept Christ’s call to labor. Our work is to seek to follow him by sharing the hope of Christ for eternity and the forgiveness, mercy, grace, generosity, and unconditional love of God. This is our work. The reward is the same. Whether you have been a Christian for a long, long time—maybe 50, 60, even 70 years. Or only for a short while—6 months or even 1 week. The reward is the same. Still, we labor on, longing for the day when we see Christ face to face. When we hear, “Well done, good and faithful servant. Well done.”

I puzzled over this passage this week and especially on Friday, which was the anniversary of my ordination—Sept. 25, 2011. When you serve the Lord in ordained ministry—as a minister of Word and Sacrament, Deacon, or Ruling Elder, you wake up and say YES to the Lord, each day. Every day, you say YES. It’s the same if we are serving as a Trustee. We wake up and say YES. We don’t do it for a reward. We do it because we have passion for the labor and the One who calls us to the work. I always know when it is the anniversary of my ordination. It’s a serious day for me. The whole day, even if I am busy caring for my flock or my family, I am listening for God’s voice, as I ask, once again, “Is this the labor to which you are calling me? Do you still want me to minister for you?” Every year, I hear the answer. STILL YES. And I answer, “I pray that you will find me faithful.”

With every year that passes, I am aware of the deepening of the commitment, my growing responsibilities, desire to be faithful, and the changing shape or form that my ministry is taking. The work gets harder. It is emotional, at times. It can be tiring. You really feel like you are laboring in the vineyard from sunrise to sunset on a scorching day—and every spiritual muscle is feeling the exertion. But you also sense the presence of all the laborers working with you, surrounding you. You feel their comforting presence in the vineyard. For this work we do for God, we never do alone.

On Friday, when I remembered how the ministers in Minnesota laid hands on me and prayed at my service of ordination and installation 15 years ago in the little town of Renville, I was preparing for an indoor picnic at the manse with the Albarella family—Kerrianne and Craig, Natalie, little Craig, and 4-year-old Aiden, whom we baptized 3 years ago. I was thinking about what food and drink they might like. Jim and I prepared cheeseburgers and hot dogs, French fries, carrot and celery sticks with ranch dressing, tomato slices, grapes, applesauce, and apple juice. We had Mickey Mouse ice cream pops and brownie bites for dessert. I have never seen children eat so many vegetables and get so excited over tomatoes before!

 I don’t recall using hospitality gifts in my ministry as often as I use them here with my ministry in Smithtown. But I have enjoyed having the people of God come to our home for ministry meetings, Bible and book studies, food, and fellowship these four years. I enjoyed the celebration of our 350th anniversary with our community and our country’s 250th with the town of Smithtown on July 4th. I didn’t know that about me—that I would enjoy these community celebrations. I always knew I would enjoy pastoral care and ministry with children and youth, but I had no idea how satisfying it would be. I knew that I would enjoy ministering to people who were grieving, sharing stories of their loved ones, and celebrating their lives. But I had no idea how sweet our worship would be, how I would look forward to it every week and season—Lent and Easter, Advent and Christmas Eve, Ordinary Time. I had no idea how this kind of ministry that I am doing in Smithtown would fill my cup to overflowing.

What makes it so special to me, dear friends, is that I am laboring with you. YOU are the ones whom God has called me to serve and nurture in faith, hope, love, and witness. You are the ones whom God has called me to encourage, to say to you, “Labor on. Don’t get caught standing around, idle. Your gifts are needed! And you are invited!”

One day, dear sisters and brothers, we will meet the One for whom we long to see face to face. We will hear him say, “Well done. Well done.”  

Let us pray. Heavenly Vine Grower, thank you for inviting us to labor in your vineyard, for the promise of our eternal reward, and our experience of your presence, grace, generosity, mercy, forgiveness, and unwavering love in this world. Thank you for this ministry here in Smithtown and for the workers gathered here to worship and be equipped for all you are calling us to do with the gifts you have given us. Thank you that we have one another and you are with us always. Use us for your glory. Give us strength and joy to persevere as your laborers, no matter the difficulty, stormy weather, or scorching heat. And fulfill our longing, dear Lord, to see your Son’s face, and hear him say, “Well done, good and faithful servant. Well done.” Amen.


[1] Frans de Waal, “Do Animals Have Morals,” NPR/TED talk (Sept. 5, 2014) accessed Sept. 26, 2026 at https://www.npr.org/2014/08/15/338936897/do-animals-have-morals.

Amazing Children of the Bible Series: Timothy

Meditation on 1 Timothy chapter 6 verses 6 through 16

Rev. Dr. Karen Crawford

First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown

Sept. 20, 2026

Stushie art, used with permission

Today, we have the joy of baptizing Valentina Bella McMaster-Castro. Valentina, daughter of Savannah McMaster and Jahn Castro, is my 21st baptism here at First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown.

Twenty-one doesn’t seem like a large number for baptisms, if you consider the number of children baptized over our congregation’s 351-year history. Twenty-one doesn’t seem like a large number even if you consider those baptized in the 201-year history of our sanctuary. Still, 21 baptisms in 4 years, to me, is a sign of health and vitality. Many Presbyterian congregations, including those on Long Island, don’t have young families anymore. If I were serving in those congregations, I would mourn like a barren woman. The Lord knows this about me and prepared my heart to serve here long before I arrived in 2022. Dear Lord, let me always be faithful to my call and never take our precious children for granted.

Our Amazing Children of the Bible Series ends today with the story of Timothy. Looking back at the children who have inspired us—Miriam, Samuel, David, Solomon, Josiah, the Little Maid of Israel, Daniel, and the Boy who Shared His Loaves and Fish, I would have to say that Timothy stands out not because he did more amazing things but because he is the most ordinary of them all. Timothy, though he has been made a saint and is honored with feast days in the Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican, Episcopalian, and Lutheran churches, has never seemed larger than life—not like the legendary Daniel, who survived a fiery furnace and a lion’s den, or David, who slew Goliath with a slingshot and a few small stones.

Friends, let me assure you that we have overwhelming evidence that Timothy existed. New Testament books, such as Acts, and several of the letters of Paul, are full of clues about his life and family, his missionary journeys and ministry. Additionally, outside the New Testament, an apocrypha book called “The Acts of Timothy,” written in the 5th century A.D. after the canon of the New Testament was complete, provides more information.

This is some of what we know of the one whose name appears as the co-author of Philippians, Corinthians, Colossians, 1 and 2 Thessalonians, and Philemon and the one who has two New Testament epistles named for him—1 and 2 Timothy. We know that he was a close companion and messenger of Paul, who was his mentor and spiritual father. Paul called him his “dear and faithful child in the Lord.” But Timothy didn’t have Paul’s personality. He was reserved and shy. He was known, however, for his pastoral care. Paul said that he could be trusted above many others for his pastoral concern and his gentle tact in dealing with awkward situations. When in prison, Paul wrote to the Christian community at Philippi, “I hope in the Lord Jesus to send Timothy to you soon, so that I may be cheered by news of you. I have no one like him, who will be genuinely anxious for your welfare. They all look after their own interests, not those of Jesus Christ. But Timothy’s worth you know, how as a son with a father he has served with me in the gospel.” (Phil. 2:19-22)

When I think of how he struggled with confidence and had to work to gain the respect of the churches he served, Timothy seems very human to me. Paul says in 1 Timothy 4:12, sending the young man to the Corinthian church, embroiled in conflicts and divisions, “Let no one despise your youth, but set the believers an example in speech and conduct, in love, in faith, in purity.” Paul again encourages his mentee in 2 Timothy 1:7-8, “for God did not give us a spirit of cowardice, but rather a spirit of power and of love and of self-discipline. Do not be ashamed, then, of the testimony about our Lord or of me his prisoner, but join with me in suffering for the gospel, relying on the power of God.” While Paul urged Timothy to step outside his comfort zone for the Lord’s sake, he also felt protective of him and worried how other churches would treat him. He warns the Corinthian church before the young man arrives, saying, “When Timothy comes, see that you put him at ease among you, for he is doing the work of the Lord, as I am.”

Timothy seems ever more human when Paul mentions the younger man’s health problems that must have made ministry a challenge but still did not keep him from the work. Paul tells him in 1 Timothy 5:23, “No longer drink only water, but use a little wine for the sake of your stomach and your frequent ailments.” Those who honor Timothy as a saint today invoke his name against stomach and intestinal disorders. Timothy’s faith journey, like many of ours, began at home. He grew up in Lystra in Lycaonia, now part of present-day Turkey. His mother, Eunice, and grandmother, Lois, were Jewish Christians. His father was Greek—a Gentile, but we know very little about him. He may have died when Timothy was young.

Paul came to Lystra on his second missionary journey and learned of Timothy’s faith and reputation. He was, as Acts 16:2 describes, “well-spoken of by the brothers at Lystra and Iconium.” Timothy was probably a late teenager at the time, when he agreed to accompany Paul. Before he could go, though, Paul had him circumcised. He was concerned that Jewish believers would not take him seriously if he were not. Also, before they left, prophecies were made about the youth (1 Timothy 1:18) and the council of elders (in 4:14) laid hands on him and prayed. Early Church Fathers, such as Augustine in the 4th century, admired Timothy for his “zeal” and willingness to immediately forsake “his country, his house, and his parents, to follow the apostle and share in his poverty and sufferings.”[1] St John Chrysostom (in his Homilies on First and Second Timothy in the 4th century) “praises Timothy’s extraordinary maturity and virtue, noting that his youth was never an obstacle to his spiritual leadership.”[2]

Timothy was with Paul during many important ministry moments. He was in Corinth “during the winter of AD 57–58 when Paul dispatched his Letter to the Romans (and he was with his mentor) in Macedonia just before Passover in AD 58; he left the city before Paul, going ahead of him to await (him) in Troas.[3] Then, Paul left Timothy to shepherd the church in Ephesus around AD 64.

Eusebius of Caesarea (in his Church History) records that Timothy was the first bishop appointed to the church of Ephesus by the Apostle Paul, a tradition echoed by other early writers such as Ignatius of Antioch. And as Timothy aged, he overcame his timidity. The writer of The Acts of Timothy describes his martyr’s death in AD 97, when he was about 80, attempting to stop the violence at a pagan festival. Ultimately, he lived as his mentor urged him to live, as a “man of God,” shunning the pursuit of riches, and pursuing instead “righteousness, godliness, faith, love, endurance, gentleness.” He fought “the good fight of the faith.” He took “hold of the eternal life.”

Today, we baptized Valentina Bella McMaster-Castro. Christ claimed her as his own. The Holy Spirit filled her with gifts that will grow and strengthen her to walk with God and be what the Lord wants her to be. And we promised, you and I, just like we promised for the other 19 children we have baptized since May 2022, that we would help her family raise her in the faith, hope, and love of Jesus Christ. How will we do this, dear friends? How will we encourage little Tina and her parents?

We will need to keep reaching out to them—when they are here and when they are not. They need their church family in this important work of raising up Tina, helping her learn to labor for the gospel and feel Christ’s loving presence with her. Just think, maybe someday, she will be like Timothy, Miriam, David or Daniel! The Little Maid of Israel. The Boy who shared his Loaves and Fish.

Sisters and brothers, may we be good examples to Tina and her family and be bold in our witness, like Paul urged Timothy long ago. May we always be faithful to our calling to ministry and never take our precious children for granted. Dear ones, let us be content, not comparing ourselves to our neighbors, never trying to keep up with the Jones, not always wanting more. May we keep from falling into the trap of pursuing riches and wander from the faith! May we, with God’s help, pursue “righteousness, godliness, faith, love, endurance, gentleness.” Fight the good fight! Take hold of the eternal life!

Let us pray.

Holy One, thank you for all the young families and young children in our congregation! What a blessing they are to us! Thank you for allowing us the privilege and joy of baptizing Valentina today! Help us to help her and her family walk with your Son all their days. Teach us to be bold and never timid or fearful in our witness. Strengthen us, like Paul urges Timothy, not to pursue riches, but instead to be content and pursue righteousness, godliness, faith, love, endurance, and gentleness. May we always be faithful to our calling and never take our precious children for granted. Lead us to fight the good fight and take hold of the eternal life.  In the name of Christ we pray. Amen.


[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saint_Timothy

[2] https://bkv.unifr.ch/de/works/cpg-4436-1/versions/homilies-of-st-john-chrysostom-on-the-first-epistle-of-st-paul-the-apostle-to-timothy/divisions/2

[3] Raymond Brown (1997), An Introduction to the New Testament, New York: Doubleday, p. 655.

Practical Resources for Churches

Everyone has a calling. Ours is helping you.

Consider the Birds

Pastor Karen shares thoughts on faith, scripture, and God's love and grace revealed through backyard wildlife.

F.O.R. Jesus

Fill up. Overflow. Run over.

Becoming HIS Tapestry

Christian Lifestyle Blogger

Whatever Happens,Rejoice.

The Joy of the Lord is our Strength

Stushie Art

Church bulletin covers and other art by artist Stushie. Unique crayon and digital worship art

The Daily Post

The Art and Craft of Blogging

WordPress.com Blog

News, Tips & Website Tutorials