Amazing Children of the Bible Series
Meditation on 1 Samuel 3
Rev. Dr. Karen Crawford
First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown
July 19, 2026

I was blessed to meet the Rev. Bill Hoffman this week and hear the story of his ministry. Bill is retiring from Montauk Community Church at the end of this month and moving to Wisconsin. He is from Long Island originally, born and raised in Hicksville.
Thirty years ago, before studying for the ministry at Louisville Seminary, he served as a forest ranger in Wisconsin, fighting wildfires for 15 years. In ministry, he served small congregations in upstate New York and Rochester, MN, and worked in prison ministry before returning to Long Island to accept a call to Montauk Community Church in August 2011.

He always had a love for small churches. And Montauk was a place that was near and dear to his heart before he became pastor of the only Protestant church on Montauk. He and his family used to vacation there when Montauk was primarily a fishing village, before the infusion of wealth that has made it a tourist destination. The glue that holds the community together today is still the fishing industry. Montauk is home to the largest commercial and recreational fishing fleet in the state.
Bill says his congregation, though affiliated with the PCUSA, draws people from a variety of religious backgrounds. They have seen themselves as a mission church since they were founded in 1928. Most people who attend are not Presbyterian. Bill has an ecumenical approach to ministry, which goes along with his call to serve small churches in small, tight-knit communities. “You don’t have to stop being what you are when you are here,” he says. You can still be Lutheran, Baptist, Methodist—whatever tradition in which you were raised. The congregation was named a “community” church in the beginning, before it became popular in the 1980s to include the word “community” in church names. The isolation—having to drive through 12 miles of “nothing” before reaching Montauk—helps to bring the community closer and nurture an island mentality, as does the ecumenical Easter sunrise service that he and a Catholic priest host on the beach and the Blessing of the Fleet that he, a priest, and a rabbi have done every June, which includes a memorial service to honor fishermen and women who have died in the previous year.
“Last year,” he said, “there were 22.”

What amazes me about Bill and his call to ministry is not the ecumenical spirit or the love of smaller congregations—which I totally get, because I am a small church pastor myself. What amazes me is that Bill continued his care for the community as a firefighter and EMT, even while serving as a full-time pastor. He says, “If you want to get to know the people of Montauk, go to the firehouse and the docks.”
Samuel had a unique calling to ministry, as well, although he was set apart for ministry before he was even born and never knew any other life except for serving the Lord. His mother, Hannah, had no children for many years. She had prayed for a child when she and her husband, Elkanah, and his other wife, Peninnah, who had many children, went every year to worship and sacrifice to the Lord at Shiloh. Eli and his two sons were priests there. One day, Eli sees Hannah, deeply distressed and moving her lips in a silent prayer, and accuses her of drunkenness. But Hannah says, “Do no regard your servant as a worthless woman, for I have been speaking out of my great anxiety and vexation all this time.” Then Eli says, automatically, “Go in peace; the God of Israel grant the petition you have made to him.” And she believes him—that God would give her a child. In due time, she gives birth, and names the boy Samuel, which means “God hears,” for she “asked him of the Lord.”
Hannah doesn’t go with Elkanah and the household the next year or the next when they go to Shiloh to offer the sacrifice. But she promises to bring the child there as soon as he is weaned, “that he may appear in the presence of the Lord and remain there forever.” She would offer him as a Nazirite; his hair would never be cut, and he would never consume anything from a grapevine. When she weans him, probably when he is 3, she brings their animal sacrifice and the child to Eli, saying the Lord answered her petition at Shiloh. “Therefore, I have lent him to the Lord. As long as he lives, he is given to the Lord.”
She sings a song that she composes, a song much like Mary’s in the New Testament, and they leave little Samuel and go home to Ramah. That must have been a hard thing to do! And they didn’t know that the sons of Eli were “scoundrels,” who treated the offerings of the Lord with contempt. They stole the raw meat brought for sacrifice to eat for themselves and threatened the servants to take it by force if they didn’t give it to them.
Meanwhile, little Samuel, wearing a priestly gown—a linen ephod that his mother would make for him and bring to him each year—would serve the Lord alongside Eli, ignoring the evil sons, and grow up in the presence of the Lord, as his mother had promised. The Lord “took note” of Hannah’s devotion and faithfulness, and she conceives and bears three more sons and two daughters. 1 Samuel 2:26 describes the growth of the boy much like Jesus is described in the New Testament: “Now the boy Samuel continued to grow both in stature and in favor with the Lord and with the people.” Luke 2:52 says, “And Jesus grew in wisdom and stature, and in favor with God and people.”
Then a man of God comes to Eli one day and tells him that because of his sons’ behavior, none shall live to old age. God would raise up a faithful priest, he said, who shall do according to what is in God’s heart and mind. That faithful priest is Samuel, who hears the voice of God calling to him at night while he is a boy, lying down near the ark of the Lord. The famous 1st century Jewish historian Josephus says that Samuel is 12 years old at the time.
Samuel serves the Lord as a priest, a nationally recognized prophet or “Seer,” and as a judge, resolving everyday disputes and conflicts amongst the tribes. He is the spiritual leader, “a key figure in keeping the Israelites’ religious heritage and identity alive during Israel’s defeat and occupation by the Philistines.”[1] And he is a military leader, leading the Israelites to victory over the Philistines after 20 years of oppression.
When Samuel grows old and his sons don’t follow in his ways, the elders of Israel come to him and demand that he anoint a king to govern them, like other nations. Samuel warns them what would happen if they had a king to reign over them, but they won’t listen.
He anoints the first king—Saul—and then, two years later, David, when Saul fails to be a man after God’s own heart. More about David next week!
But when Samuel is a mere boy, hearing the voice of the Lord for the first time and not aware that it IS God until Eli tells him, it is a sign of great things to come. As little Samuel grows up, the Lord is with him and lets “none of his words fall to the ground. And all Israel from Dan to Beersheba (know) that Samuel (is) a trustworthy prophet of the Lord.”
When I was talking to Bill on Thursday, he reminded me that our callings and fruitfulness in ministry are connected to one another. He credits the interim pastor, the Rev. Anne Stewart Miller, who served for 3 years before him, for doing the hard work of uniting what was a divided congregation. If it hadn’t been for Anne, he says, he would not have been able to pastor Montauk for 15 years.
Samuel would never have been the prophet, priest, judge, military leader, and anointer of Israel’s first kings if it hadn’t been for Eli and his mother, Hannah, who trusted God to grant her prayer for a child, though she had been unable to conceive for many years. Hannah is the one who prepared him for ministry from birth and did the hard work of loving and leaving him—the long, hoped-for child—when he was just 3 years old, to be raised and trained as a priest by Eli in the house of the Lord.
And I would not be who I am today if it weren’t for my family, especially my husband, and my teachers—and for the ministers who served the Smithtown congregation faithfully for hundreds of years before me. And, of course, for the work of the Spirit that continues in the Body of Christ, helping us to become the people God desires us to be.
Today, as we recall the life and ministry of Samuel, and as we recall other amazing children of the Bible in this series, may you be stirred to contemplate your own faith story and renew your commitment to serving Christ with your special gifts, talents, and skills. May you be inspired by others, such as Bill Hoffman, a firefighter, EMT, and small-church Presbyterian minister for 30 years, including 15 in the tight-knit fishing village and tourist destination of Montauk.
May you be inspired to help the children and youth of our community recognize God’s voice, like little Samuel at 12. And may the children and youth be blessed with the understanding that God has a wonderful plan for their lives and that their experiences and relationships nurtured within this congregation are preparing them for what is to come.
May we all remember and be empowered by the knowledge that we are precious and loved by God and God’s people.
Let us pray.
Holy One, thank you for your love, a love that is everlasting and unconditional. Thank you for the ministries of Samuel—priest, prophet, judge, military leader, and anointer of kings—and Bill Hoffman, forest ranger, fire fighter, EMT and small church, ecumenical pastor—and for our ministry here at First Presbyterian Church of Smithtown for 351 years. Thank you that you continue to speak to us and encourage us as we seek to love and serve you and our neighbors. Help us to remember with joy our faith stories and the gifts you have given us to use for your purposes. Strengthen us to nurture our next generation of prophets and evangelists to carry the gospel to this community and beyond. And bless Bill with good health and joy as he makes this transition from full time ministry on Montauk to full time family man in Wisconsin. Bless him and his wife, Valerie, for their love for your people and their faithfulness to your call. In the name of Jesus we pray. Amen.
[1] Birch, Bruce C. (2000). “Samuel” in Freedman, David Noel; Myers, Allen C. (eds.). Eerdmans Dictionary of the Bible. Amsterdam University Press.

















